User:Riccardo Guida/Templates/reviews

Please number comments and replies as X.N where X=A (reviewer A), B (reviewer B).... Au (Author) Ed (editor) and N=1,2,.... according to the skeleton below. This way you can refer to them as "comment A.1" ...

Reviewer A

Comment A.1

First comment ...

Comment A.2

Second comment ...

Reviewer B

Comment B.1

First comment

Author(s)

Reply Au.1

Concerning Comment A.1 I agree but I believe that ...